“So he can just keep threatening me until he does something concrete.”
“Yeah. It’s the flaw in the system.”
James left for rehab that afternoon. A facility in Montana. 30 days minimum, 60 recommended.
He hugged me before he left. Held on longer than necessary.
“I’ll make this right, Mom. I promise.”
“Just make yourself right,” I told him. “That’s all I need.”
After he drove away, the lodge felt emptier than it had since Robert died. Just me and Marcus’s truck in the driveway. And the waiting.
Always the waiting.
Marcus woke me at 10:04 a.m., pounding on the door.
“Mrs. Gable, get up. Someone’s trying to break into the office.”
I grabbed my phone and the emergency button, followed Marcus upstairs.
The office door was ajar. Someone had picked the lock cleanly, professionally, but they triggered the motion sensor Marcus had installed.
Inside, the safe stood open.
Empty.
“They knew the combination,” I whispered.
Marcus checked the room. Windows still locked from inside.
“They came through the house,” he said grimly. “Which means they had a key.”
James’s key. The one Robert had given him years ago.
But James was in rehab, checked in yesterday. No way to get here.
Unless he’d given someone else the key before he left.
I called the facility, asked to speak to James. The night counselor was apologetic, but firm.
“I’m sorry, Mrs. Gable. Patients aren’t allowed phone contact for the first 72 hours. It’s part of the detox protocol.”
“This is an emergency.”
“Everyone says that, ma’am. The rule exists for a reason. He’ll be able to call you on Sunday.”
I hung up, looked at Marcus.
Could Sterling have made a copy of James’s key before? Possibly.
But how would he know the safe combination?
Then I remembered the videos Robert had recorded. James had been in this office. He’d seen Robert open the safe. Could have memorized the combination. And James had been sharing everything with Bella for months.
Bella knew the combination from James.
Bella told Sterling.
We called the police. They came, took statements, photographed the open safe.
Problem is, the deputy said nothing was actually missing. I’d removed the important documents days ago.
Without stolen property, they couldn’t prove attempted burglary. Just trespassing.
“He violated the restraining order.”
“If we can prove it was Sterling,” the deputy said, looking genuinely sorry, “not some random burglar.”
He filed the report, but his hands were tied until Sterling did something they could definitively prove.
After they left, Marcus and I sat in the kitchen. Dawn was breaking. Neither of us had slept.
“He’s escalating,” Marcus said. “Testing boundaries. Seeing what he can get away with.”
“What do I do?”
“You leave today. Go somewhere he can’t find you.”
“I can’t run forever.”
“You can run until the trial. Until he’s convicted and locked up. And if he’s not convicted—if his expensive lawyers get him off—”
I shook my head. “Then I’ve lost anyway. Given up my home. Given him the power.”
Marcus was quiet for a long moment.
“Then there might be another way.”
“What way?”
“Give him what he wants,” Marcus said, “or make him think you are.”
Marcus laid it out logically. Sterling wanted the lodge, wanted revenge on Robert through me, wanted to win.
“So we let him think he’s winning,” Marcus said. “We leak information. Let them believe you’re ready to settle, ready to sell.”
“He’ll never believe that. Not after I had him arrested.”
“He’ll believe you’re scared. Exhausted. That the legal battle is too much, that you just want peace.”
“And then what?”
“Then we set up a meeting,” Marcus said. “Public place. Lots of witnesses. You agree to discuss terms, but really, you’re creating an opportunity for him to incriminate himself again. Only this time, the police are there.”
“Ready?”
“He won’t fall for it.”
“Men like Sterling are arrogant,” Marcus said. “They think they’re smarter than everyone else. They can’t resist the chance to gloat.” He leaned forward. “We make it look real. Make him feel safe. Then we trap him.”
I thought about the alternative: months of legal battles, looking over my shoulder, waiting for the next break-in or threat.
“Okay,” I said. “But we do it right. No mistakes.”
“This is entrapment, Evelyn. Anything he says could be thrown out.”
“Not if I’m genuinely discussing a sale. Not if it’s a legitimate business meeting.” I’d done my research. Stayed up all night reading legal precedents. “As long as police aren’t actively coercing him, as long as I’m acting as a private citizen exploring options, it’s legal.”
“It’s dangerous.”
“Everything about this situation is dangerous. At least this way, I control the danger.”
We spent two days setting it up. Thomas leaked information to Sterling’s lawyer, carefully worded, suggesting I was overwhelmed, considering my options.
The response came within hours. Sterling’s lawyer wanted to meet, discuss a potential settlement. No admission of guilt, but perhaps a mutually beneficial arrangement.
